Best Nipple Creams for Breastfeeding Moms to Ensure Maximum Comfort

One of the landmark moments of becoming a parent is starting the breastfeeding journey. Not only will this help you to develop a closer bond with your child, but it’s also a sign that your little bundle of joy is growing up. It’s a very exciting time for parents.

Short on Time? Click Here for Our Top Pick!

As you and your baby begin to find your breastfeeding pattern, one of the most common ailments that nearly every mom finds is discomfort and pain around the nipples. This is completely common and natural, but it can hurt a lot.

To avoid this becoming a distressing issue, it’s wise to invest in a nipple cream to protect and soothe your nipples, giving you and your baby the most enjoyable nurturing experience possible.

Product Image

Product Name



Era Organics Soothing Nipple Cream for Breastfeeding Moms

  • Metal Body

  • Remote Control

  • Motion Sensor

Earth Mama Angel Baby Natural Organic Nipple Butter

  • Metal Body

  • Remote Control

  • Motion Sensor

Yorba Organics Nipple Cream

  • Metal Body

  • Remote Control

  • Motion Sensor

Bella B Nipple Nurture Butter

  • Metal Body

  • Remote Control

  • Motion Sensor

The Honest Company Organic Belly & Nipple Balm

  • Metal Body

  • Remote Control

  • Motion Sensor

Bamboobies Boobease Natural Nipple Balm

  • Metal Body

  • Remote Control

  • Motion Sensor

Most Effective Nipple Creams to Soothe and Comfort Breastfeeding Moms

With so many brands of nipple cream to choose from, it can be hard to know where to begin. To give you the best start to this exciting stage of being a parent, I’ve compiled a list of some of my favorite nipple creams that will proactive alleviate any discomfort you may be experiencing.

1. Era Organics Soothing Nipple Cream for Breastfeeding Moms

To start my list, I’ve chosen this 100% naturally formulated nipple cream that has everything needed to provide you with a soothing and nurturing breastfeeding experience. Only certified organic substances are used in creating this cream which is ideal for alleviating cracked, chapped, irritated and otherwise painful skin on your nipples.

Thanks to this soothing effect, it’s perfect for protecting you against the symptoms of chaffing as well as reducing the problems associated with excess moisture.

Furthermore, you’ll be able to enjoy the added benefits of the powerful anti-inflammatory properties that give you all the relief you’ll need. Thanks to this special formula, this cream includes no harmful chemicals such as parabens, mineral oil, petroleum or perfumes, ensuring that it’s completely safe for your child and their well-being during feeds.

In fact, all the ingredients that are included contain high-quality hypoallergenic properties that are tested and ensured to be up to a food-grade standard.

What’s Great About It: Thanks to the unique and innovative formula, this cream boasts outstanding non-sticky properties, meaning the cream won’t stain or in any way ruin your clothing, allowing you to be as confident as possible while you’re out and about.

2. Earth Mama Angel Baby Natural Organic Nipple Butter

If you’re looking for a unique and comforting nipple butter that provides you with the relief that you need throughout the day, Earth Mama may have the product for you. This organic butter is super effective at moisturizing your nipples as well as alleviating the pains that are commonly associated with dry and irritated skin and lips.

It provides you with the comfort you need throughout the day while breastfeeding, ensuring you’re comfortable as you go about your day-to-day life.

What’s more, this nipple butter has been clinically tested to ensure that it’s free from irritants and other potentially harmful chemicals, meaning you won’t have to worry about washing it off before you nurse and breastfeed your little bundle of joy.

If you are looking for more proof of its effectiveness, this butter is commonly used by hospitals across the US and has been classed as being suitable for NICU babies.

What’s Great About It: As this highly-effective nipple butter is produced using organic oils and calendula, and is the first and original non-GMO nipple cream available on the market, ensuring that this cream has set the high bar for the rest of the manufacturers to follow.

3. Yorba Organics Nipple Cream

If you’re looking for a non-toxic, 100% natural nipple cream that’s free of all potentially harmful chemicals including parabens, fragrances, scents, petroleum, and lanolin, there’s no need to look further than the Yorba Nipple Cream.

This thick yet surprisingly non-sticky cream is ideal for soothing, repairing and healing your dry, cracked and irritated skin as well as adding protection from damage in the future.

To further the benefits, this cream is certified organic, free from animal cruelty as well as being GMO-free, passing and exceeding the USDA, PhytoTrade Africa, and PETA product guidelines, enabling you to buy safe in the knowledge that you’re giving yourself and your child the best.

This means that the cream is completely safe for your child to ingest during breastfeeding sessions without risk of any damaging effects.

What’s Great About It: The formula and recipe have been expertly perfected over the last two years, enabling you to be fully safe in the knowledge that you’re buying one of the most effective and efficient creams on the market, ensuring your breastfeeding experience is as painless as possible.

​4. Bella B Nipple Nurture Butter

If you’re looking for a plant-based nipple cream or butter that’s effective but natural, the Bella B Nipple Butter could be perfect for you. This butter is creatively and professionally produced using edible and completely safe ingredients that put the well-being of your child first.

There’s no discouraging taste or smell to the butter, so you can be safe in the knowledge that your child is safe and happy during your intimate breastfeeding sessions.

Furthermore, this butter will provide you with outstanding soothing, nurturing, and healing effects that grant you offer you comfort and peace throughout your day, minimizing your stress and pain levels so you can be completely confident in yourself.

As you could probably guess, there are no harmful chemicals included in this recipe so you can be sure that you’re only giving yourself and your baby the best.

What’s Great About It: To give you a broader idea of what’s included in this all-natural nipple butter, some of the key ingredients include shea butter, cocoa, mango extracts and avocado oil, awarding you to some of the best, most effective natural ingredients that put your health and well-being first.

​5. The Honest Company Organic Belly & Nipple Balm

Now it’s time for something that gives you everything you need and want from a nipple balm, plus a little bit extra. With this purchase, The Honest Company provides you with not only an outstanding all-natural nipple balm, but also an additional belly balm to ensure you have the softest, most well-protected skin, all in one convenient package.

The nipple balm is ideal for relieving irritation on and around your nipples as well as bringing new life to skin that’s already damaged.

Similarly, the belly balm is produced from leading natural ingredients, including omega oils and jojoba as well as a collection of fruit extracts that help to soothe and reduce the signs of stretch marks while simultaneously toning your skin, so it looks and feels better than ever before.

Both of these balms are highly effective in helping you to soothe any pains and cracks from breastfeeding, enabling you to return to your confident self effortlessly.

What’s Great About It: Easily the leading feature of this body balm package is the fact that both balms are completely natural, giving you the most beneficial skin care properties that Mother Nature has to offer. Each balm contains organic shea butter, olive oils, and calendula, all expertly blended together to provide you with the best results.

​6. Bamboobies Boobease Natural Nipple Balm

To conclude my list, I’ve chosen this highly effective nipple balm that takes care of everything you need it to. Priding itself on being 100% organic, this nipple balm is ideal for a variety of uses.

Not only will this balm soothe your nipples from irritation and pain from dry skin, it also builds up layers of protection to provide comfort throughout your entire breastfeeding period, ensuring it’s the most stress-free experience for you and your bundle of joy.

To make things even more beneficial for you and your baby, this balm compromises of just five simple ingredients, none of which are lanolin or other potentially harmful chemicals that could harm either you or your baby.

Thanks to these ingredients, the balm is completely safe for your child to ingest, meaning you won’t have to worry about wiping off the balm before breastfeeding your baby.

What’s Great About It: To guarantee the naturalness and the effectiveness of the product, it has been rigorously tested by both the USDA and the leading Oregon Tilth to ensure that every ingredient in every tub of this nipple balm is organic and free from toxic chemicals, providing you with the highest quality product possible.

Related: Finding the Best Nursing Pillow for You and Your Baby

Tips on How to Choose the Nipple Cream for You to Endure Your Breastfeeding States Comfortably

Now that you’re aware of some of the best nipple creams and butters that are currently available, it’s time to choose which one is perfect for you. But with so many to choose from, this is no easy feat. To help make your life easier, follow my comprehensive buying guide below, detailing everything you need to know to make the most educated purchasing decision.

Toxic Chemicals

As with any kind of cosmetic product, it can be full of potentially harmful chemicals that cause damage to you or your child in both the long and short term. Some of the most common yet dangerous chemicals you’ll want to avoid is lanolin, a product known to contain pesticides.

Additionally, parabens and mineral oils are two chemicals that are consistently used in cosmetics products yet are by-products from oil and petroleum industries. Alcohol, in particular perfumes or fragrances can be toxic to both you and your child.

Always remember that your child will feed from your breasts and will be ingesting these substances as they feed. Even if you use a product with harmful chemicals and wipe them off before breastfeeding, some of the chemicals may have already have absorbed into your skin and therefore there is nothing you can do about it infiltrating your milk.

The best way to approach this delicate situation is by buying nipple creams and butters that only contain all-natural ingredients. Some of the most effective creams on the market only contain five natural ingredients and, although slightly more expensive, will be better for both you and your child.

Organically Tested

Hand-in-hand with the consideration above, another aspect to look out for includes nipple creams and butters that are organic. This means that no harmful treatments or processes have been carried out on the ingredients, and therefore they are in the most effective and pure forms possible, awarding you with the greatest benefits.

Beneficial Properties

One of the main reasons you’ll be investing in nipple cream or butter is to soothe the pain experienced by your nipples and breasts during the breastfeeding stages. With your nipple cream, you’ll want to check which benefits your chosen cream will provide you with.

An all-rounded cream will soothe your pains and aches as well as moisturize your nipples to stop them from becoming dry and cracked, which can be equally as painful.

As you can see from my list, there are a ton of creams and butters that can provide you with all the protective qualities you need. As a rule of thumb, the cheaper your chosen product is, the less beneficial it will be for your body.

A Guarantee

Not every cream will be right for everyone. Some will feel sticky, some won’t work, and some may not suit your skin type. Everybody’s skin is different and will require a different kind of care. Look for nipple creams with a guarantee so if you don’t get on with it, you can simply get your money back and try again.


Breastfeeding is an essential time of motherhood, and it’s in your and your babies best interest to ensure it’s the most intimate and special time possible. One of the best steps you can take is to spend some time considering which nipple cream is best for you, ensuring that you are stress and pain-free, allowing you to focus on the more important things in life.

Leave a Comment